Received date: October 28, 2016; Accepted date: November 09, 2016; Published date: November 18, 2016
Citation: Aziz M, Yadav KS (2016) Role of Traditional Risk Factors, Inflammation and DMARDs in Cardiovascular Diseases in Rheumatoid Arthritis and Management of Lipid Profile. J Autoimmune Disord 2:4. doi: 10.21767/2471-8513.100026
Copyright: © 2016 Aziz M, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
We will review the interaction of traditional risk factors (dyslipidemia, obesity, insulin resistance, diabetes, hypertension, cigarette smoking and physical inactivity), inflammation, DMARDs in cardiovascular diseases in Rheumatoid Arthritis (RA) patients.
Rheumatoid arthritis (RA); Cardiovascular (CV) risk; Dyslipidemia; Obesity; Insulin resistance; Diabetes; Hypertension; Cigarette smoking; Physical inactivity
We present a hypothetical patient, a 60 year old man with hypertension, T2DM, and seropositive erosive RA diagnosed for 10 years. He had TG 250 mg/dl, HDL 47 mg/dl and LDL of 150 mg/dl. He is an active smoker. This diagnosed RA patient has traditional cardiovascular risk factors. In this case lot of risk factors interplay and are responsible for cardiovascular outcome in RA patients .
We would discuss the interplay of traditional cardiovascular risk factors, inflammation and treatments for RA and would also consider the current methods of cardiovascular risk stratification. We would conclude by discussing current strategies for estimating CV risk .
Raised LDL infiltrates the endothelial layer and gets oxidized in subendothelial space leading to the formation of fatty streak, eventually develop to fibrous plaques. Plaqueruptue causes thrombosis leading to blockage of the arteries leading to terminal events i.e. MI, sudden death .
van Halm et al. , did a cross sectional study and the study concluded, patients who later develop rheumatoid arthritis have a considerably more atherogenic lipid profile than matched blood donors at least 10 years before onset of symptoms. As inflammation only marginally explains the differences between the two groups, a modulating effect of lipids on inflammatory processes is hypothesised .
MTX does not have any effect on the lipid profile of RA, Westlake et al. , suggested that Methotrexate (MTX) use is associated with a reduced risk of CVD events in patients with RA. This may be important early in the disease course. The mechanism for this possible benefit cannot be fully determined from the current literature but, is likely to be multi-factorial. As disease control continues to improve in RA, future studies need to address the impact of MTX and other DMARDs or biologics on CVD, which remains the leading cause of death and a significant comorbidity in these patients. It is unlikely that a randomized controlled trial designed to determine the impact of MTX on CVD should be conducted [7-11]. However, all future studies assessing the efficacy of new or currently used DMARDs or biologics could collect data on CVD and risk factors for CVD. Furthermore, studies assessing the impact of MTX on pre-clinical atherosclerosis would also be helpful.
TNF blockade has no effect on LDL but elevated TC and HDL 5, Pollono et al. [5-12] conducted a systematic review of the literature to summarize the available evidence on lipid profile modification in patients with RA treated with TNF-alpha antagonists, with extensive searches in PubMed, the Cochrane Collaboration database (Central), and SCOPUS. No major changes were observed for ApoB/ApoA1 ratios. A small trend to increased TC was observed in patients receiving TNF-alpha antagonists, mostly due to an increase in HDL. There was a small trend to increased TG, and no changes in ApoB/ApoA1 ratio. The clinical impact of these findings is unclear, and further studies are needed to clarify the role of these lipid changes on cardiovascular morbidity in RA [13-18].
Hydroxycholoroquine has favourable atherogenic profile in RA. Tocilizumab, has an adverse effect on lipid profile on RA patients .
Inflammation and inflammatory mediators affect lipid profile in RA. Disease activity levels in RA affect lipid parameters. Choi et al.  study showed abnormal lipid profile in untreated RA patients as compared to the controls [20-25]. These national survey data indicate that RA not treated with DMARD or glucocorticoids is associated with adverse lipid profiles characterized by lower HDL-C and apolipoprotein A-I levels in persons aged > or =60 years [26-35].
As compared to the general population, RA patients have increased morbidity and mortality. Cardiovascular mortality is higher in RA patients as compared to general population [36-39]. Amongst the causes of death in RA patients, CVD is the MCC of death in RA patients [1,4-9]. Incidences of MI are higher in RA as compared to the control group [40-46]. Possible CVD outcomes in RA patients are MI, silent IHD, sudden death, heart failure. Traditional risk factors contribute to mortality in RA patients but to a certain extent, they do not completely explain the cause of mortality in RA [47-50].
High systemic inflammatory burden in RA patients plays key role in increased CV risk [37-51]. The high inflammatory burden is linked to atherosclerosis. Systemic inflammation itself changes the traditional risk factors role. Excessive inflammation is responsible for lipid paradox in RA. A correlation has been established between cholesterol and CVD outcomes in untreated RA patients [52,53].
Suppression of inflammation in RA patients leads to favourable lipid profile and reduction in CVD outcomes [53-56]. EULAR recommendations highlight the importance of early treatment in RA patients leads to favourable lipid profile by subsiding inflammation. Annual CV risk assessments are recommended for RA patients with repeat assessment on change of line of treatment . There is increased risk of CVD outcomes in inflammatory arthritis patients. Inflammation has now been proved to be a risk factor for CVD outcomes and it has also been well established subsiding inflammation decreases CV risk in RA [29-33]. Systemic inflammation associated with RA disease activity increases CV events in RA patients. EULAR recommends the multiplier of 1.5 for RA patients who meet 2 of 3 criteria- 1) Disease duration >10 years; 2) RF/anti CCP positivity; 3) Presence of Extra articular manifestation. But in spite of applying this, there is a substantial portion of population that still remains unidentified [57-65].
Role of inflammation has been suggested in pathogenesis of atherosclerosis in RA patients [66-68]. CRP, fibrinogen and cytokines play role in mediating this process [69-72]. Pro inflammatory molecules, cytokines, endothelial dysfunction, dyslipidaemia, insulin resistance and oxidative stress play vital role in CVD in RA .Many studies have correlated inflammatory burden ESR and CVD risk [73-80]. Inflammation contributes in all stages of atherosclerosis [7,20,41]. The mechanisms that play role in synovial inflammation are same in atherosclerosis plaque formation [39,70].
TNF, IL-6 and IL-1 associated with RA, play central role in atherosclerosis [81-83] CRP, is an independent predictor of CVD risk. Higher IL-6 levels are associated with acute coronary syndromes . CRP mediates uptake of LDL by macrophages and formation of foam cells and eventually plaque formation [85-86].
Traditional risk factors and disease activity both have effect on lipid profiles in RA patients. Inflammatory mediators cause both qualitative and quantitative changes in lipoproteins . The protective action of HDL is impaired in RA and eventually leads to CVD events. Both qualitative and quantitative changes in lipoprotein should be assessed in RA patients.
McCarey et al.  showed that statins can mediate modest but clinically apparent anti-inflammatory effects with modification of vascular risk factors in the context of high grade autoimmune inflammation. 6 months statin therapy in RA, demonstrated favourable lipid profile, decrease in disease activity and reduced inflammatory mediators. These findings show use of statins in RA improve CV risk through both lipid lowering and anti-inflammatory effect.
Insulin resistance and diabetes
Homeostatic model assessment (HOMA) calculation examined the relationship between IR and inflammation in RA. The study showed direct relationship between IR and grade of inflammation . Parameters considered in this study were CRP, ESR and waist circumference. Parameters considered were CRP, IL-6, TNF-ALPHA 40% association was shown between RA and DM .
TNF blockade, no reduction in IR in 6 months; Kiortsis et al. . The results suggest that infliximab treatment may have beneficial effects on insulin sensitivity in the most insulin resistant patients with RA and AS.
Adalimumab, no reduction in IR in 6 months, Rosenvinge et al.  RA patients with active disease showed marked insulin resistance that was not influenced by anti-TNFalpha therapy despite a reduction in systemic inflammation during the treatment.
IR improved with infliximab treatment Tam et al., after infliximab treatment, insulin resistance improved as reflected by the significant reduction in the Homeostasis Model Assessment Index. Total cholesterol, HDL-cholesterol, LDL-cholesterol, triglycerides, and apolipoprotein B (apoB) levels all increased significantly from baseline. Nonetheless, the atherogenic index, LDL-cholesterol/HDL-cholesterol ratio, and the LDL/apoB ratio remained unchanged. Infliximab improves insulin sensitivity and alters lipid profile in patients with active RA.
Tocilizumab, drop in IR, Schultz et al.  showed inhibition of IL-6 signalling improves insulin sensitivity in humans with immunological disease suggesting that elevated IL-6 levels in type 2 diabetic subjects might be causally involved in the pathogenesis of insulin resistance. Furthermore, data indicated that inhibition of IL-6 signalling decreases Lp (a) serum levels, which might reduce the cardiovascular risk of human subjects.
MTX, decrease in IR, Dessein et al. , Methotrexate use in RA may improve CVD risk through a marked suppression of the acute phase response. Dietary intervention prevented the increase in total and low-density lipoprotein cholesterol upon acute phase response suppression.
TNF alpha blockers, HCQ, found reduced risk of DM in RA, Wasko et al.  among patients with rheumatoid arthritis, use of hydroxychloroquine is associated with a reduced risk of diabetes.
According to WHO, individuals with a BMI >30 KG/m2 are considered obese . Arthritis patients have a higher BMI as compared to the general population [1,3,54]. Obesity was proved as a significant CV risk factor in RA as in controls . With the use of bioelectrical impedance studies, characterization of actual body fat composition was done and it showed RA patients have more body fat for a given BMI as the healthy controls .
Stavropoulos et al.  showed in individuals with RA, BMI cut-off points should be reduced by 2 kg/m2 (that is, to 23 kg/m2 for overweight and 28 kg/m2 for obesity). The equation developed can be used to accurately predict BF from BMI in RA patients. These findings may be important in the context of the cardiovascular comorbidity of RA.
Giles et al.  showed using abdominal CT scans that male RA have more visceral fat and female RA patients had more subcutaneous fat than controls for similar BMI and waist circumference. These studies showed BMI is the underestimation of CVD risk in RA. They found higher VFA in men with RA, and the more potent association of VFA with cardiometabolic risk factors in men and women with RA, which may contribute to cardiovascular risk in RA populations.
McEntegart et al. found hypertension in RA . The study showed in RA patient population, diastolic blood pressure was higher than in controls and thrombotic variables were elevated compared with controls. These features are identified as potential additional cardiovascular risk factors in the RA patients studied. Prospective studies of risk modification may permit the identification of factors which could lead to a reduction in the known increased cardiovascular risk in RA.
Maki-Petaja et al. found arterial stiffness in RA . This study demonstrates that both ezetimibe and simvastatin reduce disease activity and inflammatory markers to a similar extent in patients with RA. Therapy is also associated with a concomitant reduction in aortic PWV and improvement in endothelial function. This suggests that cholesterol lowering per se has anti-inflammatory effects and improves vascular function in RA. NSAIDS, Glucocorticoids raise BP [27-28]. Mazzantini et al.  showed the prevalence, demographic and health characteristics with arthritis in southern Brazil were similar to other parts of Brazil and other developed countries.
Cigarette smoking is the strongest risk factor for RA. Costenbader KH,  showed in the large cohort, past and current cigarette smoking were related to the development of RA, in particular seropositive RA. Both smoking intensity and duration were directly related to risk, with prolonged increased risk after cessation.
Cigarette smoking is the biggest modifiable risk factor for CVD. Yang et al.  in their study showed meeting a greater number of cardiovascular health metrics was associated with a lower risk of total and CVD mortality, but the prevalence of meeting all 7 cardiovascular health metrics was low in the study population.
Prevalence of smoking was higher in RA and was associated with increased severity of RA. Wolfe F  showed Quantitative relationships exist between smoking extent and RF positivity, RF concentration, nodule formation, radiographic progression, and pulmonary disease. These 3 latter effects are independent of RF positivity or concentration. Smoking does not contribute to alterations in disease activity measures, but appears to play a role in overall severity of disease.
RA patients are significantly less active than controls and so have the worse lipid profile . Exercise interventions improve functional status in RA and greatly benefit CV risk. van den Berg et al. recommended more than half of the health care providers expressed a need for further education on the promotion of physical activity. Further research should focus on the best way to train health professionals in the promotion of physical activity in patients with RA.
CV risk estimate
FRS -Higher FRS associated with higher CVS risk in RA . Chung et al. concluded a higher Framingham score was associated with a higher calcium score (odds ratio [OR] = 1.20, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.12 to 1.29, P<0.001), and the association remained significant after adjustment for age and gender (OR=1.15, 95% CI 1.02 to 1.29, P=0.03). A higher Framingham risk score is independently associated with the presence of coronary calcification in patients with RA (Figure 1 and Table 1) [88-90].
|Tchol||230 mg/dl||230 mg/dl||5.95 mmol/I|
|Systolic BP mmHg||137||-||137|
|On Medication for Hypertension||Yes||-||-|
|Mother or father with heart attack or stroke before age 60||-||Yes||-|
|High/low-risk European Country||-||-||High|
|Predicated 10- year risk||10% MI or coronary death||13% MI or stroke||3% Fatal CVD|
FRS and SCORE include only traditional CV risk factors, not inflammatory markers thus they underestimate CV risk in RA. Traditional risk factors and inflammation both play role in cardiovascular risk [1-3]. RRS incorporates inflammation into the score but still a poor estimator for CV risk; since it was calibrated using mean hs CRP 2.0 mg/l which is below of the average RA patient .CRP levels change in RA during disease flares and treatment phases.
EULAR recommends a multiplier of 1.5 for FRS or SCORE if a patient has 2 or more of the following: RA disease duration >10 years, RF, ANTI CCP, extra articular manifestations.
Management of lipid profile and CVD risk in RA
This review highlighted the importance of inflammatory burden as the key driver in pathogenesis of CVD and hence a key CVD risk factor. Hence, this emphasizes the EULAR recommendation of adequate disease control in order to lower CV risk . Therefore, effective CV risk management should include treatment of conventional risk factors and tight control of disease activity. The potent suppression of inflammation with biologic therapies in RA results in favourable profile and adequate control of CVD risk. Thus, the key recommendation for treatment of RA patients is early aggressive treatment of RA with disease remission and low disease activity as the clinical goal. Lipid profiles should be monitored and reassessed and treated with lipid lowering drugs accordingly.
Carotid plaque complications are related to RA disease activity. Ultrasonography assessment of cIMT is useful tool to stratify RA patients with CV risk. Hence, carotid ultrasonography may thus be useful in CV risk assessment to enhance the identification of RA patients with increased CV risk.
The aim of our review was to discuss and analyse role of traditional risk factors, inflammation, DMARDs on Cardiovascular risk in RA patients. We reviewed findings of all previous studies and collected all evidences to support the role of traditional risk factors, inflammation, DMARDs on Cardiovascular risk in RA patients. Finally, our review also stressed on accurate estimating of CV risk which will help in primary and secondary prevention of CVD in RA patients.
The CVD risk in RA is related to the systemic inflammation associated with RA as well as to traditional risk factors. Early treatment of RA suppresses inflammation significantly and has favourable effect on the lipid profile. Our conclusion is tight and sustained disease control lowers CV risk and also we recommend screening all probable risk factors of cardiovascular diseases.
A multidisciplinary case management approach to CVS risk reduction is warranted. A collaborative approach between PCP and Rheumatologist will help to design a comprehensive management plan for improved outcomes in RA patients. Such approach will reduce cardiovascular morbidity and mortality both primary prevention with behavioural and environmental modifications should be emphasized.
Aggressive lipid-lowering therapy in patients with RA and cardiovascular diseases will improve cardiovascular morbidity and mortality rates and alleviate symptoms . In addition, statin therapy has been shown to reduce the incidence of stroke in patients when lipid levels were reduced.
Ideal blood lipid levels can be accomplished only by adherence to lifestyle and pharmacological regimens. Adherence in the collaborative approach to the management of abnormal blood lipids will have a more profound impact on the reduction of cardiovascular and cerebrovascular morbidity and mortality.
All diagnosed RA cases should be screened for all probable risk factors at their first visit. Adequate management of RA patients with consideration all screened CVD risk factors.
In RA patient’s inflammation interplays with traditional risk factors and affects the lipid profile in RA patients.
Early suppression of inflammation through control of disease activity modulates the clinical outcomes.
All RA patients should be screened for all CVD risk factors at their first visit.
How inflammation modifies traditional risk factors in RA. More studies are required to show prevalence of traditional CV risk factors comparing to the general population.
All Published work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
Copyright © 2019 All rights reserved. iMedPub LTD Last revised : April 18, 2019